NewsLocal News

With deadlock from abstained vote, independent oversight proposal fails in Tulsa City Council

With deadlock from abstained vote, independent oversight proposal fails in Tulsa City Council
Add 2 News Oklahoma as a Google Preferred Source

TULSA, Okla. — After multiple public safety departments and the public thoughts on an independent oversight committee to Tulsa City Council Oct. 14, councilors voted 4-4-1, dooming the proposal.

Chief Jonathan Brooks, who officially took over on Oct. 1, gave his thoughts during a nearly five-hour council work session earlier in the day on what the proposal would mean for his department.

"This ordinance, it could run the spectrum of it could be helpful or it could be harmful. I don't know," Brooks said.

Chief Brooks added that having accountability conversations is something he's looking forward to doing regardless of what happens in council. "It's important for me to go directly to our community," Brooks said. "Have those transparent talks and be available to them."

The chief echoed what other public safety leaders said at the previous meeting: that oversight and reviews already take place.

"I'm going to be utilizing our community from every aspect of the city to make decisions from where I sit now," Brooks said.

Chief Brooks and those opposed to the proposal said it feels focused on the police department. Councilor Lori Decter Wright, who co-wrote the proposal, said it's not.

"I'm not aiming this at police any more than I'm aiming it at animal services, the fire department, or any other in town that citizens say to me makes their neighborhood feel safer," Decter Wright said.

Councilor Vanessa Hall-Harper, who also helped write the proposal, weighed in as well.

"There are certain things that the community needs to see and feel confident about, not saying that the things that you're doing or hope to do and propose to do is not going to work," Hall-Harper said. "We're talking about the trust and accountability on this side."

The item also sparked a personal argument between councilors Christian Bengel and Jackie Dutton during the work session.

“You don’t say, ‘Thank you for your service,’ and then, ‘Let me tell you what a piece of s*** you are.' Because that’s kind of what that implies to me,” Bengel told Dutton at the table.

“I’m sorry you took it as that implication,” Dutton said.

“Well, you need to choose your words carefully,” Bengel responded.

During the 5pm city council meeting, councilor Dutton voiced support for the committee idea.

“The cost of (past lawsuits against the city) coming out to $47 million pales in comparison to the $500,000 it’s going to cost,” Dutton said.

As for the public weighing in, retired fire marshal Mark Sipe voiced opposition to former Tulsa public safety employees not being allowed on the committee.

“I don’t qualify because I’m being discriminated and punished against for my service to this community and being denied the right to serve on that board,” Sipe said during public comment on the agenda item.

Unlike prior oversight groups, this oversight committee wouldn’t have been just for police, but also for reviewing the fire department, emergency management, and animal services, among others.

One resident voiced support it for holding City of Tulsa Code Enforcement accountable.

“I look at Admiral Flea Market (and) the vendors who have sat out there for many years. And a lot of code enforcement officers, they’re always changing the rules.”

Tulsan Julie Skye referenced Human Rights Watch’s assessment of TPD after the shooting of Terence Crutcher.

“Tulsa police use physical force on Black people 2.7 times more frequently than they do on white people," Skye quoted. "They use pepper spray 3.6 times more frequently, tasers 2.9 times, dog bites 2.1 times.”

After almost an hour of councilor discussion, the item failed with a 4-4 vote, with councilor Anthony Archie abstaining.

"This is not about opposing accountability or transparency," council chair Karen Gilbert said in her reasoning for voting no. "Those are important responsibilities of local government. It is about making sure that whatever we put in place is effective, thoughtfully developed, and built on collaboration.”

Councilor Phil Lakin mentioned in his reasoning against the committee that a city council working committee for public safety could be an idea he and other councilors support.

Another council item for altering and/or extending the current downtown curfew for juveniles is expected to be voted on in the Oct. 21 meeting.